International Mutual Funds vs Nifty 50: What the Last 3 Years Reveal

Introduction

Imagine owning shares in Apple, Tesla, or Nestlé without dealing with foreign broker accounts or foreign exchange hassles; that’s the promise of international mutual funds in India. These funds pool rupee investments, providing Indian investors with easy access to overseas equities and ETFs. Although the opportunity is open to most retail investors, adoption remains low. In this blog, I’ll walk you through what international mutual funds are, show every fund available in India over the last three years, and compare how they performed versus the Nifty 50 so you can see whether global diversification has actually paid off.

What are International Mutual Funds (IMFs)?

International mutual funds are India-domiciled mutual fund schemes that invest in foreign equities or overseas ETFs. As an investor, you invest in Indian rupees, and the fund house handles currency conversion, overseas custody, compliance, and portfolio management.

Your returns, therefore, come from two sources:

• Performance of the foreign market/assets

• Currency movement (INR vs foreign currency)

International mutual funds enable Indian investors to diversify beyond the domestic market and gain exposure to global sectors, countries, and companies without the need to open a foreign brokerage account. They are typically referred to as a fund of funds.

A Fund of Funds is a mutual fund that invests in other funds instead of buying shares of companies itself.

So, in the case of international mutual funds in India:

• Your money → goes into an Indian mutual fund

• That Indian fund → invests in overseas mutual funds or global ETFs

• Those overseas funds/ETFs → invest in actual foreign stocks

That’s why the structure is fund → fund → stocks.

Disadvantages of International Funds of Funds

1. Higher Expense Ratios (Double Cost Structure)

   Funds of Funds have two layers of costs—one at the Indian fund level and another at the level of the underlying overseas fund or ETF. Even if each layer appears small individually, the combined expense ratio can meaningfully reduce long-term returns, especially over longer holding periods.

   
   

2. Unfavorable Tax Treatment

   They fall under the broader category of “specified mutual funds” / non-equity funds (similar to debt funds) when computing capital gains. If you hold for more than 24 months, gains are treated as long-term. Under the current law (post-July 23, 2024 changes), LTCG is taxed at 12.5% (without indexation). If you sell/redeem within 24 months (2 years) of purchase, gains are treated as short-term and taxed at your applicable income tax slab rate.

   
   

3. Currency Risk Can Work Both Ways

   While a depreciating rupee boosts returns, a strengthening rupee can reduce or even negate gains from overseas markets. Currency movements are unpredictable and add an extra layer of volatility to returns.

   
   

4. Dependence on Overseas Market Cycles

   International funds are influenced by global economic conditions, interest rate cycles, and geopolitical events. During periods when global markets underperform Indian equities, these funds may lag domestic benchmarks for extended periods.

   
   

5. Investment Caps & Inflow Restrictions

   Due to SEBI–RBI overseas investment limits, fund houses may be forced to pause fresh investments once industry or AMC-level caps are reached. This can prevent investors from investing when valuations are attractive or disrupt systematic investment plans (SIPs).

   
   

6. Limited Control Over Underlying Holdings

   Investors have no direct control over stock selection or regional allocation. Performance depends entirely on the underlying ETF or fund manager’s strategy, which may not always align with investor expectations.

   
   

7. Lower Transparency Compared to Direct Equity Funds

   Although disclosures are mandatory, investors do not get real-time visibility into individual foreign stock trades. Portfolio disclosures are made periodically, making it more challenging to respond to rapid global market changes.

Regulatory framework

SEBI permits Indian mutual funds to invest in overseas mutual funds and overseas unit trusts (MF/UTs) under specified conditions. This opens up a regulated pathway for domestic mutual funds to access global investment vehicles.

Indian Securities Exposure Limit - Overseas MF/UTs must not hold more than 25% of their assets in Indian securities. Indian mutual funds must ensure this limit is respected at the time of investment and on an ongoing basis.

Monitoring & Rebalancing Rules - If, after investment, the overseas fund’s exposure to Indian securities exceeds 25%, Indian mutual funds must follow a monitoring and rebalancing process.

• 6-Month Observance Period: Indian mutual funds can observe whether the overseas fund rebalances back under the 25% limit. No new investments can be made in that fund during this period.

• 6-Month Liquidation Period: If the limit is not restored within the specified observation period, the Indian mutual fund must sell/exit the investment within the next six months. If the breach is corrected during the liquidation window, forced exit may not be required.

Overseas Investment Limits (SEBI + RBI) - To control foreign exchange outflows, India imposes strict caps:

• Industry-wide limit: USD 7 billion

• Per AMC limit: USD 1 billion

Once these limits are reached, AMCs must pause fresh investments into overseas assets.

(This is why you may have seen international funds temporarily stop new inflows in recent years.)

How International Mutual Funds Performed Over 1 Year Compared to the Nifty 50

Key Interpretations from the 1-Year Return Comparison

1. Strong Outperformance vs Domestic Benchmark

   Out of the 27 international mutual funds analysed, 25 funds outperformed the Nifty 50 returns (10.45%), resulting in a success rate of over 90%. This indicates that, as a group, global equities delivered superior returns compared to Indian large-cap equities over the past year.

   
   

2. Global Equity Rally Played a Major Role

   The outperformance was largely driven by strong rallies in US technology stocks, global growth sectors, and select emerging markets, which benefited funds tracking indices such as NASDAQ-100, S&P 500, FANG+, and global technology themes.

   
   

3. Currency Impact Boosted INR Returns

   A weaker Indian rupee against the US dollar during the period amplified returns for Indian investors. Even when overseas markets delivered moderate gains, currency depreciation acted as a tailwind, improving INR-denominated performance.

   
   

4. Wide Dispersion Across Funds

   While most funds beat the Nifty 50, returns varied significantly, ranging from high single-digit gains to returns exceeding 40%. This highlights that fund selection matters—not all international exposure delivers the same outcome.

How International Mutual Funds Performed Over 3 Year Compared to the Nifty 50

Key Interpretations from the 3-Year Return Comparison

1. Consistent Outperformance Over the Medium Term

   Out of the 26 international mutual funds, 17 funds outperformed the Nifty 50 over the 3-year period. This translates to a success rate of around 65%, indicating that while global diversification continued to add value over the medium term, the outperformance was more selective compared to the 1-year results.

   
   

2. Compounding Magnifies the Performance Gap

   While the Nifty 50 delivered relatively steady returns over the three-year period, many international funds benefited from strong compounding, resulting in returns significantly higher than the domestic benchmark. The gap between global funds and the Nifty 50 is notably wider than in the 1-year comparison.

   
   

3. US and Global Thematic Funds Led Returns

   Funds with exposure to US equities, technology, AI, and global growth themes dominate the upper end of the return spectrum. These segments benefited from sustained earnings growth and market leadership over the past three years.

   
   

4. Currency Tailwind Remained Supportive

   The depreciation of the Indian rupee over the period continued to enhance INR-denominated returns. For long-term investors, the impact of currency fluctuations is compounded alongside market returns, thereby strengthening overall performance.

Before we conclude the blog, let us invite you for a 1:1 financial planning session.

Book Your Slot

Conclusion

The analysis reveals that international mutual funds have delivered strong relative performance compared to the Nifty 50, particularly over the past year, with more than 90% of the funds outperforming the domestic benchmark. This was driven by a global equity rally, strong performance in US technology and growth-oriented sectors, as well as a supportive currency environment. Over a longer 3-year horizon, the results remain positive but more selective, reinforcing that global diversification adds value over time, though outcomes vary across regions and strategies.

A significant factor influencing returns has been currency fluctuations. The depreciation of the Indian rupee amplified INR-denominated returns, making international mutual funds one of the more accessible ways for Indian investors to benefit from a falling rupee without directly investing overseas. At the same time, currency movements can work in the opposite direction, which makes allocation discipline essential.

Overall, international mutual funds offer a convenient and regulated route to global markets. An investment adviser would use them as part of a diversified portfolio rather than as return-chasing instruments. Used appropriately, they can help mitigate country-specific risk, enhance diversification, and improve long-term portfolio resilience.