Open Ended Fund vs Closed Ended Fund: The Structural Edge Investors Must Understand

Two friends invest in mutual funds on the same day. One checks the fund’s value daily and can redeem units anytime. But the second person can’t withdraw until a fixed maturity date, even if markets fluctuate. The difference lies in the fund’s structure of whether they are open-ended or closed-ended funds. Both the structures come with their own benefits and decide how money enters, exits, and grows within the fund. The chosen structure decides everything from liquidity to how fund managers make investment decisions.

What Are Open Ended Funds

Open Ended Mutual Funds stay open for both buying and redemption throughout their existence. They do not have a fixed maturity period, and the total fund size changes as investors enter or exit. All transactions occur directly through the fund house, not on any stock exchange.

1. Structure An open-ended fund remains available for investment and redemption at all times after the New Fund Offer (NFO). There is no restriction on the number of units that can be issued or repurchased.
   

2. How Open Ended Funds Are Priced The value of each unit is determined by its Net Asset Value (NAV). NAV reflects the fair market value of the fund’s holdings after deducting expenses and liabilities. It is calculated at the end of each trading day, so the price investors receive or pay always matches the current value of the portfolio.
   

3. Transaction Process Investors buy and redeem units directly through the Asset Management Company (AMC). Each transaction is processed at the day’s declared NAV, ensuring transparent and uniform pricing across all investors.
   

4. Investment Options Investors can participate through lump sum investments or systematic plans such as SIP, Systematic Transfer Plan (STP), and Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP). The structure also allows partial withdrawals or switches to other schemes managed by the same fund house.
   

5. Liquidity of Open Ended Mutual Funds Open Ended funds offer high liquidity. Units can be redeemed on any business day, and proceeds are typically credited within a few days. Exit loads may apply for withdrawals within a short duration, often the first year.
   

6. Performance Visibility NAV data, portfolio composition, and performance history are published daily. This transparency helps investors monitor consistency and compare results across funds and time periods.
   

7. Accessibility of Open Ended Mutual Funds Minimum investment amounts typically start at ₹500 to ₹1,000. These funds are available to retail investors, NRIs, and institutions, making them widely accessible.
   

8. Types of Open Ended Mutual Funds The structure includes equity, debt, hybrid, liquid, gold, international, and ELSS schemes. ELSS funds carry a three-year lock-in under Section 80C, offering tax benefits to investors. 
   

What Are Closed Ended Funds

Closed Ended Mutual Funds operate with a fixed corpus and a defined tenure. Unlike open-ended funds, these schemes issue units only once during the New Fund Offer (NFO) period. After this window closes, no new subscriptions are accepted, and investors cannot redeem units with the fund house until maturity.

1. Launch and Unit Issuance A closed-ended fund raises capital during its NFO by issuing a specific number of units. Once the offer closes, no additional units can be created. The fixed pool of money gives the fund manager a stable base to plan investments across the scheme’s duration.
   

2. Trading and Market Liquidity After the NFO, units are listed on a stock exchange. Investors who wish to exit before maturity can sell their holdings in the secondary market. The traded price may differ from the Net Asset Value (NAV), depending on demand and supply. Units can trade at a premium or a discount based on market perception of the fund’s performance.
   

3. Lock-In and Maturity Each closed-ended scheme has a predetermined tenure, often between three and five years. The investment remains locked until this maturity date. At maturity, the fund liquidates its portfolio and returns the proceeds at the prevailing NAV. Some funds may convert into open-ended schemes with investor consent and approval from the AMC.
   

4. Fund Management Approach A fixed corpus allows fund managers to invest in less liquid or long-term assets without worrying about daily redemption pressure. This stability supports disciplined strategy execution and may create scope for higher returns if managed efficiently.
   

5. Pricing and NAV Behavior While the NAV is calculated daily based on portfolio value, the market price on the exchange can fluctuate independently. Investor sentiment, market movement, and demand-supply factors influence this divergence.
   

6. Accessibility and Minimum Investment Investors can participate only during the NFO. The minimum investment usually starts at around ₹5,000. Once the NFO closes, entry into the scheme is possible only through secondary market purchases.
   

7. SIP, STP, and SWP Options Systematic plans such as SIP, STP, and SWP are generally unavailable in closed-ended funds. Since no fresh units can be issued after the NFO, these structures cannot support recurring investments or withdrawals.
   

8. Track Record and Data Availability Closed-ended funds are new at the time of launch, so they do not have prior performance history. Investors must rely on the fund’s objectives, AMC reputation, and portfolio strategy before investing.
   

Key Differences Between Open Ended Fund Vs Closed Ended Fund

The core distinction between Open Ended Funds and Closed Ended Funds lies in how money moves in and out of the scheme. open-ended structures stay liquid and accessible, while closed-ended ones operate with fixed capital and tenure. The table below outlines these differences across key investment factors.

How To Choose Between Open And Closed Ended Mutual Funds

Choosing between Open Ended Mutual Funds and Closed Ended Mutual Funds depends on how long you plan to stay invested, how much liquidity you need, and how actively you prefer to manage your portfolio. Each structure serves a different investor temperament and goal type.

1. Investment Horizon Investors with short- or medium-term goals often prefer Open Ended Funds because they allow exits anytime without waiting for maturity. Those with long-term objectives, such as wealth creation over three to five years or more, may favor Closed Ended Funds, which maintain a fixed corpus and discourage premature withdrawals.
   

2. Liquidity Requirements Open Ended Mutual Funds provide high liquidity, enabling investors to redeem units on any business day. Closed Ended Mutual Funds lock investments until maturity, offering limited liquidity through exchange trading. Investors comfortable leaving funds untouched may benefit from the stability of a closed-ended structure.
   

3. Goal Orientation If you prefer flexibility and frequent rebalancing, Open Ended Funds fit well since they allow systematic investing and withdrawals. Closed Ended Funds impose investment discipline by restricting access, which helps investors stay invested through market fluctuations without reacting to short-term volatility.
   

4. Market Timing and Deployment In Closed Ended Funds, the entire corpus is invested at launch, which can work well if the fund starts in a favorable market. Open Ended Funds spread investments over time through SIPs, which reduces timing risk and supports rupee cost averaging during volatile phases.

   
   

5. Fund Management Style Closed Ended Mutual Funds give managers a stable asset base, letting them invest in long-term or less liquid opportunities without redemption pressure. Open Ended Funds require liquidity buffers to meet redemptions, which may limit full deployment of capital but improve responsiveness to investor flows.
   

6. Accessibility and Investment Size

   Open Ended Funds are easier to access, often starting at ₹500–₹1,000, and suit investors building wealth gradually. Closed Ended Funds typically demand a larger lump sum during the NFO period, appealing to investors with surplus funds ready for long-term allocation.
   

7. Tax and Lock-In Factors Both fund types follow the same tax rules based on whether they are equity- or debt-oriented. Only ELSS schemes, a type of open-ended fund, qualify for Section 80C tax deductions with a three-year lock-in. Closed-ended schemes generally mirror their tenure as the lock-in period.
   

In summary, Open Ended Mutual Funds are designed for investors seeking liquidity, flexibility, and ongoing engagement with their portfolio. Closed Ended Mutual Funds work better for those who prefer commitment, strategic discipline, and a long-term outlook without the distractions of daily market access.

Get Started

Conclusion

Every mutual fund structure carries its own rhythm. Open-ended funds move with the investor, while closed-ended funds hold their ground for the long haul. A Mutual Fund Advisor can help align the fund’s structure with an investor’s liquidity needs, investment horizon, and comfort with market movement. When the fund type matches the way an investor manages money, portfolio decisions become clearer and outcomes more consistent.

FAQs

Is SIP open-ended?

SIPs are available only with open-ended mutual funds. They allow fixed, periodic investments (monthly/quarterly), enable rupee cost averaging, and build holdings over time. Closed-ended schemes do not accept SIPs after the NFO.

Can we sell open-ended mutual funds anytime?

Yes. open-ended units can be redeemed with the AMC on any business day at the declared NAV. Locked categories (for example, ELSS) and early exit loads may restrict immediate proceeds. Transactions occur directly with the fund house, not on exchanges.

Are closed-ended funds good for retirement?

Closed-ended funds suit lump-sum investors with a multi-year horizon who value enforced discipline. They lack regular SWP payouts and carry liquidity risk, making them less convenient for retirees who need steady income. open-ended funds with SWP typically work better for retirement cash flow.

Is ELSS a closed-ended fund?

No. ELSS schemes are generally open-ended funds with a mandatory three-year lock-in for each investment. Most ELSS funds accept continuous subscriptions, including SIPs, while enforcing the statutory lock-in per contribution.